Review of Adam Rovner. In the Shadow of Zion: Promised Lands before Israel. New York: New York University Press, 2014.
By Rich Robinson
Before there was the modern state of Israel, there were other potential Jewish homelands in unlikely places such as Grand Island, New York; Uganda; Angola; Madagascar; Tasmania; and Suriname. Who knew?
Adam Rovner knew. He is Professor of English and Jewish Literature and directs the Center for Judaic Studies at the University of Denver. In the Shadow of Zion explore these little-known proposals for places that would better the lives of European and Russian Jewry, even save them from potentially troubling fates. Between 1820 and 1948, survey teams scouted out improbable locales, sent reports, and advocated for what could have turned out to be an alternative history.
These efforts were not only geographical, but also very much ideological. There were, on the one hand, “Zionists,” and on the other hand there were “territorialists.” Zionists were content to hope for a rebirth of the Jewish nation in the land of ancient Israel, even if it would take some time. Territorialists saw a need for immediate action and an establishment of a land—any land—for Jews. Among the latter’s objections to settling in what was then called Palestine was the likelihood if not certainty of ongoing war with the existing Arab population. Territorialists also tended towards promoting Yiddish; the Zionists, Hebrew. Thus is it clear that today’s Zionism, in its many manifestations, was only one option on the table for many years.
Rovner covers six proposals that were made. In the first half of the 19th century, Mordecai Manuel Noah envisioned a safe haven in Grand Island, New York, hard by the city of Buffalo and also Niagara Falls. At one point, he hoped to create a Jewish state as one of the United States of America. A city called Ararat, or it cornerstone at any rate, was established, in which not only Jews but Native Americans, thought to be descendants of the “ten lost tribes,” would also join in. In the end, Noah turned his sights to the land of Israel, seeing Ararat as only a temporary location. Not many Jews accepted Noah’s proposal or his self-aggrandizing ways. The project foundered almost from the start.
The second effort came in the first few years of the 20th century, this time in Uasin Gishu, East Africa, supported by none other than Theodor Herzl, Eliezer Ben-Yehuda, and others. Africa, the so-called “dark continent,” stirred the imagination of Europeans and their colonial aspirations. Great Britain advocated for this “Uganda Plan,” at least partly to shore up Britain’s colonial claims to the region against Germany and to stop a flood of Jewish refugees from entering the UK. But voices also rose up in opposition: British settlers in Uganda did not want the area to turn into what they called “Jewganda” (p. 92, Kindle edition). Nor were Russian Jews in favor.
Third up was Angola’s Benguela Plateau, a proposal also made in the early 20th century. And in the mid-20th century, Madagascar came up as a potential locale, especially for Polish Jews. (Yes, Africa figures much in these efforts, partly due to fear that settling in Palestine would provoke hostility from existing Arab populations, and perhaps also because these were colonial lands where “settling” could be encouraged.) There were legends that Madagascar’s inhabitants were descendants of the “ten lost tribes” (those tribes seem to get around the world quite handily). Even the Nazis, perversely, supported Madagascar as a kind of island ghetto for Jews, who would have no autonomy there.
The fifth proposal takes us to Port Davey in Tasmania, another mid-20th century idea. Australia wanted to see “white” settlement there, so this proposal seemed to find a congeniality with Australia’s hopes. With little to no native population, any conflicts would be staved off. Finally, the mid-20th century also saw Suriname, in South America, as a possibility (formerly Suriname was known as Dutch Guiana). Slavery enters into the mix there, along with intermarriages such that “Afro-Creole women still wear Star of David pendants” (p. 265). The pre-existing Jewish presence in Suriname was thought by some to facilitate making it into a settlement for European Jews.
In the Shadow of Zion is an absorbing and even an entertaining read. The above sketch cannot do justice to the panorama of locales, individuals, writers, politicians, and Jewish infighting that Rovner highlights so well. Clearly, Jews (and others) held to a wide variety of ideas on how to address what was often called the “Jewish question,” that is, the inability for Jews to assimilate into the nations in which they lived, whether by their own efforts or those of others. The history that Rovner uncovers holds lessons for today’s Zionists, and the antisemitism that is often part of the story lets us know that those who today conflate Zionism with their hatred of Jews have a precedent. For whether it concerned Africa or Australia, antisemites managed to entangle their Jew-hatred with Jewish aspirations for a homeland, wherever it might have been conceived.
Read this enlightening book and contemplate what Jewish life might be like today had our national home been in Madagascar, Tasmania, or an American island where Jews freely intermingled with native American.